Acrylic vs. Gel vs. Silk Nails: Which is Best for Nail Health?

Question
I would like to have as few chemicals as possible.  My nails look so bad as they peel.  I need nails put on but I don't know whether to get acrylic, silk or gel.  Which is the lest harmful to my nails?  What are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
Thank you very much.
Jody

Answer
Hi Jody,
 Here is a recent question that I answered, so I think it covers what you are asking:

-What are the pros and cons of UV gel nails?
A-The gel itself, when used properly, should not cause any long term damage. Having said that, how the nail is maintained and/or removed is key to avoiding damage. Your nails will remain shiny for at least 2 weeks and you are less likely to see any yellowing. The cons for gel nails would be that SO many salons are trying to pass off acrylic nails as gels(thus charging more for the service).

Q- If I do get gel nails, how often do I need to go in for maintenance?
A-You will need to maintain these every 2-3 weeks.

Q-Is this procedure ultimately worse for my nails?
A-No, not at all. Please be sure to go to a reputable salon where you can communicate with the person who is performing your service. I would also ask for a consultation. That way, you won't feel obligated to stay if you aren't comfortable. Almost all gel products come in an opaque jar and are typically clear, clear pink or white. An acrylic nail with a gel topcoat is NOT a gel.

Q-Are acrylics or wraps damaging to my nails?
A-Acrylics and wraps are not damaging, but the process in which they are applied and removed can be. Overfiling, overpriming and improper electric file usage are the likely culprits in nail damage, no matter which product you choose.

So, the most important step that you can take to protect your nails, is to find a nail technician that is properly licensed and skilled. Do not be shy about asking to see the technician's license.

In terms of how many chemicals are in each, that is a tough one to answer. All of the products that you have mentioned have acrylates. I am seeing a lot of clients with sensitivities to these. Poly gels are the only gels on the market that have eliminated these from their product.

I hope that I have answered your question, but if I haven't, please let me know Jody :)

Brooke Gilliam