Love Beauty >> Love Beauty >  >> FAQ >> Fashion >> Costume Jewelry Collecting >> Jewelry, Gems, Minerals

Is It Real? Identifying Authentic Italian Gold Jewelry


Question
Hello.  I stumbled upon your answer to a different question on the Internet and thought perhaps you could advise me too.  Years ago, I received a gift from a co-worker who had just traveled to Italy.  It is a drama mask pin, which she claimed is "Italian gold".  I have never ever worn this, as I think it's kind of ugly, plus the "nose" on the mask protrudes about an inch and is sharp.  I was going to put it into the charity donations, but then remembered her comment about it being "Italian gold".  I certainly do not want to give something away that is gold, but if it really isn't, I have no use for it (if it's real, I'll have it melted down and re-created).  Are there always stamps on gold?  I cannot locate any kind of stamp, even looking through my loop.  I took it to a jeweler I usually deal with and he said he didn't "believe it to be real".  But couldn't say that with 100% conviction.  What's your opinion?  Thanks!

Answer
Peggie, what you need is a jeweler who will do a test on the metal. They will possibly need to slightly scratch the surface on a more hidden part of the back to test properly.  That sort of test is not totally accurate in getting to the actual karat but can tell quickly if the item is gold or is gold plated or gold filled instead.

Items should be stamped and generally any gold items made in Italy I have seen are always stamped properly.  This item should be marked with either the numerical or karat mark if it is karat gold through and through.  14k is 585 and 18k is 750.   

The Italians built a reputation being one of the first countries to promote the jewelry products of that country by putting "country of origin" on items. Hence, much gold jewelry made in Italy does say Italy somewhere on the item along with the quality mark (metal content such as karat).  I know there are fakes around but I find it hard to believe a legitimate piece of karat gold jewelry from Italy would not have the karat marked somewhere on the item. There would also be a makers mark in most cases.  If your item has no marks whatsoever, that part is suspicious and leads me to believe costume and not karat gold.

Still, to know for certain, Peggie you will need to get that test done.  Call around to see what jewelers will do it since all will not have someone in-house to do the testing.  The test takes very little time but do expect a minimal charge.

Best wishes with the drama mask.  Finding out what you truly have will solve the problem, certainly.

God Bless and Peace.  Thomas.    Ask me stuff anytime... : )