Best Ash Brown Hair Dye for Coarse Hair: Palty, Hoyu, Prettia Comparison

Question
Okay so I have light golden brown hair with a tint of red in it, but I want to dye it dark ash brown. I was thinking about using a Japanese hair dye, such as Palty Jewelry Ash or Hoyu Beautylabo or Prettia Elegant Ash. I only want to use these because my hair is coarse naturally and I heard these work fine for coarse hair. My main question is which dye should I use? Which dye will make my hair a perfect dark ash brown?

Answer
Hi :D
So i've used Prettia Elegant Ash on my also natural course hair, but my hair was a darker shade of your current color. Prettia Elegant Ash is the one im definitely recommending! The others you listed are actually for oily hair types, people might say that they work good on course hair because they have oily/course hair.
Have any more questions? Dont hesitate to ask!