* Kat Dennings (Max): Often seen wearing deeper, more dramatic shades. Think reds, berry tones, and sometimes even vampy shades. Matte finishes were also common.
* Beth Behrs (Caroline): Usually wore lighter, more neutral shades. Think pinks, nudes, and sometimes a subtle coral. Often seen with a glossy or satin finish.
Specific Colors/Brands (Based on Fan Theories and Recreations):
* Reds: MAC Ruby Woo, NARS Dragon Girl, and similar classic reds have been suggested for Max.
* Berries/Plums: Shades like MAC Diva, or a similar deep berry, have been mentioned for Max.
* Nudes/Pinks: For Caroline, suggestions include MAC Creme Cup, or other light pink and nude shades from brands like Maybelline, L'Oreal, and Revlon.
Tips for Recreating the Look:
* Max: Go for bold, saturated colors with a matte finish. Don't be afraid to experiment with deeper shades.
* Caroline: Opt for lighter, more natural-looking colors with a slightly glossy or satin finish.
Without specific episode information or confirmation from the show's makeup artists, it's impossible to provide an exact answer. The suggestions above are based on general observations and popular opinions from fans and makeup enthusiasts.